Sunday, April 19, 2015

Current Scenario of Reservation System in India

Recently, in India, there was buzz about Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, Father of Indian constitution at 14th April. It is late but great that we started to celebrate our legacy instead running after western culture due to new Indian government.

The one of the most discussed part in India is “Reservation” regarding Indian constitution.  Reservation is extra privileges is given based on caste. The aim of the reservation was to create a society where all sources and opportunity must be available equally for all, economically and with social stand. At the time independence, there was a large gap between citizen’s social and economic power and social and instructive position for underprivileged communities. The scenario was such matured behavior as untouchability, banned from temple existed.  So, in a consequence of reform, Dr. Ambedkar proposed “Reservation” in Indian constitution of India.

From ancient time, the Indian population is divided into four categories based on their karma. Kshatriya (soldier), Vaishya (businessman) Brahman (priest) and Shudra. Most respected is Kshatriya and lowest honored is Shudra.

Indian constitution divided census into four categories (caste). General, Other Backward Classes (OBC), Schedule Caste (SC), Schedule Tribe (ST). And they gave reservation to OBC, ST, and SC. This casting has been defined by birth same as ancient method. The reservation was given in education, government jobs and political career with excessive facility. Indian constitution made arrangement in such that central and state government can promote reservation separately. Meanwhile, the Supreme Court of India said, however, this reservation can be exceeded more than 50%. Current scenario of reservation in India.

Caste
Reservation Percentage
OBC
27%
ST
7.5%
SC
15%

In a newly founded constitution, there was provision that these arrangements will be reviewed periodically and changes will be made (of course in decrement). Yes, it was reviewed many times, but not a single time it was decreased, which means that the reservation was not fulfilling its objective or there was more politics of vote bank which one is more than 33%. The reservation was only for 10 years after independence, extended each time in political interest by working government.

After looking mood of motion, other communities are coming forward to have reservation backed by their vote bank. Massive movement of Gurjer in Rajasthan for reservation can be not forgotten. In 2014 Vidhan-Sabha election, Gurjer voted party at promise of having a significant state reservation in Rajasthan. A Muslim has kept demanding reservation for many years and government spending crores to pleasing them, which is a violation of the Indian constitution too. Maharashtra Government made a reservation for Marathi people in private jobs to collect at least some vote.

Well, even after more than 60 years of independence, do we really needs such reservation policies? No, I don’t think so, nor you should. I am not saying that a significant part of the population does not need reservations. Yes! They do, but which people? If we analyzed, reviewed data, we will find our right candidates. Basis of caste for the reservation does not even look okay. At the same time we need to identify what amount of extra privilege should be given.  

There are many people from general category who does have talent, but doesn’t have the resources to fulfill their dreams. Same as people from reservation category, don’t even know the benefits of these things. In which, education plays, creative role, gives maturity of their thinking and how to use it. In this race, some dreams have been buried and it is continuous.

The objectives of the caste based reservation had been accomplished. The new scenario is different. Literate India does not give response to untouchability or anything else which makes another one feels small based on their caste. Complexity of reservation is very high and it won’t be a big deal if reviewing policy properly placed without any political influence. 

No comments:

Post a Comment